Each industry and/or project has its own design drivers whether that be cost, reliability, time to market, value and assembly or some combination of the above. These various design drivers can conflict with each other or even conflict between departments. Procurement focuses on piece cost along with supplier selection and development. Manufacturing is often focused on just-in-time delivery. Quality Control is concerned with a supplier’s processes and ensuring good incoming quality and longer-term reliability of parts. Design engineers try to complete the design while meeting the initiatives of each department.
Product Design Phases
When engineers have an initial design, the focus shifts to the building of prototypes and validating the design. Historically, this has necessitated working with small prototype shops to build initial designs. This phase of the project is where the engineers:
- Learn and define critical characteristics
- Identify intellectual property
- Validate the critical design parameters
As this process progresses, engineers prefer to work with manufacturers where immediate service and feedback is received. While this works well to validate the design, the learnings related to the design do not transfer very well from a prototype manufacturer to a production contract manufacturer who specialize in the specific project drivers (cost, quality, etc..). In fact, once a contract manufacturer is chosen, a redesign of the PCB layout to optimize cost or reliability to better match the capabilities or equipment of the chosen manufacturer is often necessary. Additionally, many production contract manufacturers are located offshore which results in poor service due to time zone or language differences. Ask any design engineer, they could likely give you examples of working with a supplier where learnings did not translate well between design stages.
The PCB progresses through the design stages and moves from a prototype manufacturer to the initial launch (usually onshore) and then finally to a mature production contract manufacturer (often overseas). Each transition turns into a small project in and of itself. Maintaining the goals of cost, quality, delivery, and design learnings present a challenge through each transition. The inefficiency of such a process adds considerable costs in terms of additional engineering, procurement, and quality engagement.
It would be ideal to find a single contract manufacturer like MacroFab that can work with you on your prototype and help you create a DFM, then go straight to production, without having to onboard another CM and go through these challenges.
Selecting a Contract Manufacturer
The selection of the contract manufacturer typically occurs after the initial design validation. Procurement departments usually work with engineering to create a list of potential suppliers. Quotation packages are sent out and then preliminary quotes are received 2 to 6 weeks later. Only then can cost and capital estimates are compared against real quotations. Of course, this usually takes another 2 to 4 weeks to properly compare all the bid packages from potential suppliers and reach a consensus on the proper partner moving forward.
Once work begins with the selected supplier, design elements are modified to work well with the supplier processes and equipment. Approving part substitutions, modifying design packages, and a review of those packages add additional weeks and unnecessary cost. Through this process, the intent is to keep intact those critical design characteristics identified so much earlier during the prototype builds and testing.
For many design engineering firms, success depends on contract design work. In order to receive contract work, it is imperative that engineers operate as efficiently and accurately as possible to provide a good value proposition. Even in large companies, where designs are completed internally, timelines and manpower are critical issues to manage. I would like to introduce you to a new electronics PCB design model that addresses these outlined issues and works with the majority of designs. This model assists in controlling cost against targets from the initial phase forward while working with the same manufacturing group. This manufacturing group is engaged from the initial design prototype(s) all the way through production. Imagine a scenario where you can upload your bill of materials along with your Gerber files (or native files) and receive immediate quotations for prototypes as well as allowing you to view the cost reductions and impact as you scale. Once the initial design is complete, you may upload your design files and have immediate prototype costs and production cost scenarios based on the volume scale. Consider that this same service allows you to retain learnings from prototype phase to production phase. This same tool implements revision control and allows you to scale your design as your production scales. Most of the laborious and time-consuming tasks so boorishly described at the beginning of this article can be streamlined or even eliminated. Does this sound appealing so far? To make it interesting let’s add a few more elements:
- Outstanding service where you can speak with a knowledgeable person immediately and receive valuable feedback on manufacturing-related needs.
- Designs manufactured in days, versus weeks.
- Onshore (USA) manufacturing
- A large pool of contract manufacturers all with guaranteed capabilities to manufacture your design.
The MacroFab Advantage
MacroFab has put together an electronics manufacturing process that compliments the design process. MacroFab’s innovative online tools link the entire design and manufacturing process from initial design prototypes through production runs. MacroFab does much more than just contract manufacturing. You can immediately see your costs and approve alternate parts. Does your design require rigorous levels of critical validation testing prior to the receipt? If so, MacroFab can build custom test fixtures to validate your critical characteristics. If you require other value-added services such as programming, manufacturability reviews or warehousing MacroFab can assist with that as well.
For designs where volumes exceed the “on demand” services, MacroFab creates custom quotations as well. MacroFab’s methods of pairing the manufacturing process with the engineering design process are revolutionizing the way electronic designs are quoted and moved from prototype to production scale. The savings are measured not only by the time (and money) realized by the contract designers but also in the satisfaction of knowing that you have exceeded your customer’s expectations.
Was this post helpful? Let us know in the comments below.